“Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know.” - Ernest Hemingway
These are not terribly surprising words coming from a man whose last action was to place the barrel of a shotgun into his mouth. A highly-renowned and influential writer, it’d be hard to say Hemingway was not an intelligent man. But then, as Joshua Ferris once wrote, intelligent people are not always guided by their intelligence.
What I believe Hemingway was saying is that smart people understand better than others that life ends in death, that it all gets wiped out, and that since no afterlife is provable or viable, then everything is meaningless and shitty and people are terrible and the world is awful and boo-hoo why are we alive. Hemingway is observing that intelligent people think that death is the biggest backdrop to life, and so all intelligent people who see this as the truth will not be able to hang onto their happiness for long. And I think many perfectly intelligent people still have this view today. But there’s something incredibly stupid about this mentality. Something lazy, fatalistic, simplistic about narrowing it all down to death.
Most intelligent people believe in the theory of evolution, and isn’t the next rational step the evolution of thought? The evolution of perspective? If we are bound to a limited time in this life, isn’t the smartest thing to do is find happiness in whatever tiny thing might provide it?
The developmental psychologist Howard Gardner had a theory about multiple types of intelligence and not a single one (Spatial, Linguistic, Logical-mathematical, Bodily-kinesthetic, Musical, Interpersonal, Intrapersonal, Naturalistic) recognizes the ability to appreciate happiness. I think people who might excel at one or several of these intelligence areas might also fail at the ability to draw happiness from it.
This already feels like a rambling post, one of those things that’s hard to prove, that other intelligent people might call a poorly reasoned argument. But something within me, when encountering a quotation like Hemingway’s, or the oft-pessimistic viewpoint of many other people whose opinions can be found on the Internet, feels that one type of intelligence has been vastly ignored. Pushing psychological disorders and chemical imbalances as far away from the conversation as they’ll go, misery is stupidity, cynicism the aged degradation of brain cells. The ability to appreciate the lives we have been given is the utmost intelligence, the one that will some day decide who has the will or the strength to survive from those who do not.
“The moral? to recognize that our best chance of contentment lies in taking up the wisdom offered to us in coded form through our coughs, allergies, social gaffes, and emotional betrayals, and to avoid the ingratitude of those who blame the peas, the bores, the time and the weather…Bad sufferers, wretched souls who have been betrayed in love or excluded from parties, who are pained by a feeling of intellectual inadequacy or a sense of social inferiority, but who learn nothing from such ills, and indeed react to them by engaging a variety of ruinous defense mechanisms which entail arrogance and delusion, cruelty and callousness, spite and rage.”
” – Alain de Boton, How Proust Can Change Your Life


